Book Review by Peter McKenzie-Brown
GeoDestinies: The inevitable control of Earth resources over nations and individuals, by Walter Youngquist.
500 pages; 29 chapters plus preface and epilogue. Originally published in 1997 by National Book Company, in Portland, Oregon. Born in 1921, Youngquist updated the book in 2012, and made the updated version available to all online; click here to download the PDF. He died in 2018.
Why I chose this book: The topic for this month is “the
future.” This book explores the future by going deep into the past.
The image above is the cover of the version I have just reread;
I first read it shortly after it came off the press, perhaps in 1999. The image
below, on the right, is the cover of the later, revised version. In my opinion,
this book is superb. It is well documented (up to eight pages of endnotes per
chapter) and uses graphics occasionally to illustrate trends.
Themes: The book doesn’t spend a
lot of time on the high-profile issue of climate change, although that is
certainly part of its agenda. Instead, Youngquist focuses on the rapid
depletion of formerly abundant volumes of natural resources – resources which predate
the arrival of humankind.
The gist is that Earth’s resources are now being so rapidly used
that the existence of vast human populations may soon be in peril. Numerous resources
are being degraded and depleted — aquifers, topsoil, hydrocarbons, minerals, lakes,
forests, farmland and so on and so forth. Rather dramatically, he somewhere
says that once an area is covered with asphalt, it will never again be farmed.
The author cites examples of smaller countries with access
to uncommon mineral resources. For short-term gain, they may extract and export
what they own. But then what? Their only mineral is gone. What’s left for their
Consumers pay little attention to resource limits, but there’s
a fair amount of chatter about the impact of carbon emissions on the climate. I
suspect that most of the people in this club are also concerned about this
issue. However, Youngquist argued, mainstream experts repeatedly tell us not to
worry, essentially promoting blind faith in miracles: In some mysterious way,
we will find a smooth and easy transition to a clean, green, renewable utopia. The
message I’ve heard often over the years is that we all need to obey the three Rs:
Reduce, reuse and recycle. Yes, but….
Youngquist argues that we are living dangerously by
destroying astonishing amounts of non-renewable resources. To use the example
Albertans are most familiar with, we’ve been shipping oil and gas east, west,
and south through vast networks of pipelines. Our society, and most of us in
this club individually, have benefitted from these businesses. But these binges
can’t be repeated in this province. Non-renewable energy is finite in volume – by
It took more than 500 million years for geologic forces to
transform plant and animal residue into fossil fuels — coal, oil, and natural
gas. It will take less than 500 years for humans to extract and burn them. We
live during a brief blip in Earth history – an ecological hurricane. The
author’s core message is a blunt warning. “The momentum of population growth
and resource consumption is so great that a collision course with disaster is
inevitable. Large problems lie not very far ahead.…In some respects, the Twenty-first
Century will be like the Twentieth Century in reverse.”
The public believes that adequate “renewable” substitutes
will become available as needed. Alternative energy is not clean, green and
free. The facts, though, are more complex. Scaling up to replace non-renewable
energy would require vast land area, roads, power lines, and backup for when
adequate wind or sunbeams are unavailable. Manufacturing solar panels requires such
critical minerals as cobalt, gallium, germanium, indium, manganese, tellurium,
titanium, and zinc. Each wind turbine requires tons of concrete, steel, and
other resources. As we seek those resources, another cycle begins.
I strongly recommend this book.